Score: 10

"Entertaining!"

submission: Prelude to Joy III

date: May 17, 2006

Well, I must say, I've seen a lot of random flashes in my day, most of them being pure crap produced by hopeless 13-year-olds with a bootlegged copy of Flash. This one, though, was quite good.

Score: 8

"Very good"

submission: An American Revolution

date: April 8, 2006

I'm not sure why some reviewers are criticizing the style of this work. I liked it - how it was strictly monotone, how the scenes and rooms faded into darkness. It seemed to fit. As far as the animation itself, the only time I really disliked it was in the very first scene (the fan blades rotating, which was done rather poorly). Other than that, the frame-by-frame was pretty good. Quite enjoyable.

Score: 7

"Very David Firth-y"

submission: Sweetly Moor Ep1

date: March 26, 2006

First off, I liked it. But it was clearly a rip-off of David Firth's style. I realize you've already addressed this, but I disagree with your statement that "Nowadays, it's hard to do anything creepy that isn't like his work." On the contrary, there are many different ways to make something creepy without using Firth's drawing and animation style, as you did. Still a good animation overall, though.